[REVIEW] Ah Girl: A Child’s-Eye View of a Family Coming Apart

There is a particular kind of local film that succeeds not because of its plot but because of its faces. Gek Gek’s Ah Girl is one of them. It has an interesting premise, a family under financial and emotional strain seen through a child’s eyes, and a lead performance that carries most of the film’s emotional weight. At the Special Preview, what stayed with me was the acting, particularly from its young cast.
Ong Xuan Jing: The Heart of the Film
Ong Xuan Jing’s performance as the title character is surprisingly superb. I say “surprisingly” because child performances so often come across as rehearsed, with emotions performed rather than felt. Xuan Jing avoids this in almost every scene, and she sustains it across the film.

Consider the scene where Ah Ma has her hair cut. It is a small domestic moment, but Xuan Jing turns it into a confrontation. Her feistiness, her resistance and her tears say everything the scene needs. Nothing is overplayed, and the child’s anger and helplessness come through without a line of explanation.
Then there is the piggy bank scene, where she takes it out and says she can help with the family bills. In the wrong hands this could tip into sentimentality. Xuan Jing plays it with a child’s earnestness, sincere and a little proud, and that makes it quietly devastating. She isn’t acting like a child who understands money. She is acting like a child who understands that her family is in trouble and wants to fix it with the only thing she owns.
The most harrowing moment comes when she tries to stop an uncle from taking her younger sister away. The panic, the physicality and the unguarded fear are the rawness of a child, not a polished imitation of it. Child actors are rarely trusted with emotion this exposed, and Xuan Jing delivers it. Across the film, in many other scenes, she captures that same raw emotion again and again. Gek Gek deserves credit for drawing it out of her.
Sidney Wong: The Scene-Stealer

My personal favourite, though, is Sidney Wong. Her comedic moments are well captured by Gek Gek, who clearly understands how to use her. Sidney’s androgynous image makes her an unusually interesting presence. She doesn’t fit a familiar mould, and that makes her fresh to watch.
I often found myself watching her reactions rather than whoever was speaking. Much of comic acting lives in reaction, and Sidney has an instinct for it. A good example is the scene where her mother brings the children back for cheese sticks. Her little flying gestures are cute and raw, with no sense that she is performing for the camera. Moments like this are easy to miss, but they are the texture that makes a character feel real. In my view Sidney steals a good number of scenes, and she does it without pulling focus from the story.
Ang Geck Geck: A Director With a Voice

What I admired most about Ah Girl is Ang Geck Geck’s storytelling method. She tells a heavy story, a family under financial strain and coming apart, through the eyes of a child, and that perspective gives the film its personality. Instead of explaining the adults’ problems outright, she lets us feel them through the children’s reactions, which is why the emotional beats land even when the script leaves gaps.
Her handling of tone is just as interesting. Comedy and heartbreak sit side by side, and she moves between them without the film feeling confused. Sidney Wong’s comic moments never undercut the more painful scenes. They make the family feel like real people who still find things to laugh about in hard times. She also builds the film’s world from small, lived-in nostalgic details rather than big statements, and I found that approach refreshing.
Above all, Ang Geck Geck draws remarkable performances from her young cast. Raw, unguarded child acting like this doesn’t happen by accident. It takes a director who knows how to create the space for it, and she clearly does.
The Adults: Doreen Toh and the Parents
Doreen Toh is as good as ever, a dependable anchor in the ensemble. In some scenes, though, she shows slight signs of dementia, and I couldn’t tell whether that was the actor’s choice or the character’s. If it is a character choice, the film should signal it more clearly. If it is an actor’s choice, it reads as ambiguity rather than intention. Either way, a clearer signal would have helped.
The parents are harder to assess, mostly because of what the script gives them. Carrie and James play a couple whose marriage is coming apart, but the film doesn’t let us in.
Nostalgia, and the Problem of the HDB Blocks
The film’s quiet pleasure is its nostalgia. The bubble gum, the 10-cent Seng Pao drink and the spider-catching all evoke a Singapore childhood. They land because they feel lived-in rather than inserted as a checklist, and for anyone who grew up with these small rituals the effect is warm and instantly recognisable.
That is why the setting deserves a note. In the scene where the younger sister goes missing, the HDB blocks look like BTO flats rather than the older estates this story belongs in. I understand the practical reasons. Filming in older estates like Toa Payoh or Bukit Merah would be more restrictive, with tighter permissions, more control needed and less freedom to shoot. But when a film builds its world on nostalgia, the architecture should match the memories. Older blocks would have grounded the period far better and strengthened the emotional pull of the scene.
What Didn’t Work
I had reservations on three fronts.
The maturity of the young characters. I’m not fully sold on the level of maturity the children display. The love track between Ah Girl and the boy is the clearest case, as their conversations feel too grown-up for their age. The dialogue sounds like adult sentiments placed in children’s mouths, and it sits oddly beside the otherwise believable performances. A lighter, more innocent treatment would have been truer to how children that age speak and feel.
The parents’ breakup. This is the film’s biggest gap. I couldn’t understand the breakup between Carrie and James. What is their internal struggle? What is the reason behind it? The film gives us very little. It simply mentions that the husband is into fat ladies. That is a reason offered as a punchline, not a motivation, and it reduces a marriage collapse, the very thing the child at the centre is reacting to, to a throwaway line.
One scene sharpens the problem. James, half-naked with a towel wrapped around him, dances in front of the Japanese caretaker while holding his crotch. It is an interesting scene, and it made me immediately assume the two would end up together. Instead he ended up with a pregnant Malay woman. The scene sets up an expectation that the film neither pays off nor explains, so it feels more like a detour than a revelation about the character.
Swee Geck’s return. The film never explains why Swee Geck was returned from the supposed foster family. This is a plot point with real emotional consequence for the child and the family, yet the film moves past it without comment. For a story so invested in the child’s perspective, the omission stands out.
Verdict

Still, I enjoyed the film. The premise is interesting, and the children’s performances are superb, so much so that they outshine the adult storyline around them. That is both the film’s strength and its imbalance. The kids give it heart and humour, while the parents’ story, which should be its emotional spine, is left underwritten.
Ah Girl is slightly less than perfect, but it has a lead performance that deserves major attention, a scene-stealing comic presence in Sidney Wong, and nostalgia that rings true. It is worth watching for the kids alone.
All the best to Gek Gek in the Golden Horse Awards nominations. Do Singapore proud.
Ah Girl is nominated for three awards at the 63rd Golden Horse Awards
Best New Director (Ang Geck Geck)
Best Adapted Screenplay (Ang Geck Geck)
Best New Performer (Ong Xuan Jing)
The winners will be announced on November 22, 2026 in Taipei.
Upcoming Screenings in Singapore
Thursday, November 19, 2026: Opens at Filmhouse.




Comments